ANNIE GALLUP – Lucy Remembers Her Father (Gallway Bay Music)

Lucy Remembers Her FatherIn what is, unquestionably, her finest solo work to date, Annie Gallup, one half of Hat Check Girl, has crafted an intimate, conceptual storytelling album about the past, mortality and the power and value of memory. Her musical and personal partner, Peter Gallway, contributes bass and keys, but otherwise this is all down to Gallup who plays the guitars, ukulele and lapsteel that make up the spare instrumentation. A poet and theatrical writer/performer as well as a songwriter, she often adopts a spoken approach to her work that prompts comparison with Laurie Anderson, notably so here on the beat poetry influenced ‘All The Money In The World’ and the vocally double-tracked hushed and confessionally delivered ‘Being Her Child’ on which a girl seeks to trace herself and her own identity in memories and photographs of her late mother, a theme to which she returns on ‘Understudy’.

It opens on ‘Paper’, which, in less than two minutes, sketches an image of fragility and emotional vulnerability (“Strike a match, I curl to ash in the kitchen sink”) yet also subtly conjures anger at an unreliable lover as she describes a chain of cut-out figures “joined at the fist a string of dolls each like the other girls you kissed.”

Featuring keening lapsteel, ‘Loyalty’ both illustrates her ability to weave an enchanting melody out of a minimal setting and to immediately draw you into her narrative, a reflective tale of perhaps misguided youthful allegiance (“I was hard to shake”) to those undeserving of it in the need to feel wanted, opening with the conversational “Back when we were friends she had a lover who was once an extra in a Woody Allen film, it might have been Manhattan. I never got to meet him. He was swept away. That was exhibit A of how she inspired passion. Exhibit B changed frequently, C was mythical and she was an unreliable narrator” as she goes on to talk of “the familiar ache of intoxicating cruelty” and of how “I was still terrified by everything I wanted.”

Her stories range freely, in ‘Bluebird’ the narrator is a WWII veteran who, following in his father’s footsteps, who fought at Amiens, recalls being injured at Normandy when his parachute snagged a tree, leaving him to “hang there helplessly with a shattered chest.” Whereas, ‘Strange Boy’ charts a doomed relationship with the oddball, lonely kid who grows up to become the singer’s commitment phobic cynical and unromantic (“I gave him a poem for a Valentine. He wrote suggestions and corrections in the margins”) lover and eventually a stranger who “stayed up all night to watch me sleep” but “was gone at dawn”, leaving behind, in an image linking back to the opening track, “a fleet of paper airplanes” which “had crashed into the sheets.”

Only one track exceeds the four minute mark, and yet Gallup packs in as much compelling narrative as a short story. The musically spooked, spoken ‘Coyote Highway’ is a case in point, a heartrending tale of a couple discovering, on her birthday, that he has a terminal illness, making the most of the remaining time together (described in mundane but moving imagery) that ends on an ominous note as, hearing the coyote’s that haunt the area, she wonders “Are they getting closer?

Before this becomes more of a literary essay than a review, let me just also direct you to the woozily dreamy, self-explanatory titled ‘Il Ne M’aimera Jamais (He Will Never Love Me)’ with a melody that evokes Civil War era folk and the plucked guitar album closer ‘Luminary’ with its wondering what might happen when old flames, meet again somewhere down the line, one having found fame, the other not.

More particularly, you owe it to yourself to listen to the album’s two 24-carat diamonds, the simply titled ‘Story’, a spoken four minute novella about a nine-year-old American boy who, his father dying on a quest to find a missing uncle in the slums of Lagos, happily becomes one of the streetkids until, finally found and returned to his mother in New York, now grown and pondering the existential questions “Who would he be if he had lived? Who would I be if I hadn’t been found?

And, of course, the quite magnificent title track as, backed by wheezing keyboards, the narrator’s lost in reverie of the father who left home before she was born but remained in her life, his housefull of strangers playing tune after tune”, their times together “Poor in existential angst and solitude. Rich in mosquito bites, moths around the porch light… Poor in long distance calls and cruises. Rich in homegrown tomatoes and river rocks.” And in a final line that transcends sentimentality to strike deep into memories of a life richly lived and loved, “Poor in pedigree and regrets.” A sublime work of profound emotion and evocative poetry enfolded in simple but intoxicating melodies it’s one of the finest releases this year; now, how about a novel?

Mike Davies

Artist’s website:

ANNIE GALLUP – Ghost (Gallway Bay Music GBM108)

GhostAs well as having being one half of Hat Check Girl for the past five years, the Ann Arbor born singer-songwriter has an extensive solo career to her name, dating back to her debut release in 1994. This is her tenth solo album and, along with musical partner (and now husband) Pete Gallway on hand as ever, although this time only on string bass, it features Paul Simon’s go-to fiddler Gabe Witcher and David West on dobro and mandolin.

Maintaining the “quiet conversations” of 2012’s Little Five Points, it’s a gentle, reflective collection of hushed folk songs wrapped around tales of relationships, of love and loss, at least two of which specifically seem to call on her own family background, first up being ‘Diamond Ring’, a fiddle led number about her mother’s ring, serving as a symbol of the women herself and prompting Gallup to question the gulf between what’s remembered and what was. Indeed, the album title and the sleeve image of the ladder to an open attic, underlines the nature of memories and things hidden away that permeates several of the tracks.

The late Jack Hardy, a Greenwich Village folkie and playwright, is the inspiration behind the elegy and memories of the mandolin backed ‘Ghost Town Kite’, it’s rural tone spilling over into ‘West Memphis, Arkansas’ where she sings of there being four ways out of the dead-end town, the road, the rail, the river and, so the lyrics suggest, motherhood. Geographical location underpins the next track too, ‘The Battle of Brooklyn’, an uncluttered telling of the Revolutionary War battle as the redcoats marched on the town’s outnumbered rebel defenders.

If Hardy has inspired one track, banjo wizard Danny Barnes actually gets a song named after him as Gallup recalls seeing him in concert for the first time, wisely opting to keep the track’s own banjo work understated. Then it’s back to matters of the heart with ‘A Loves B’, a tenderly played bittersweet story of a true love, but one in which he hides a secret life, sleeping around and playing away from home while the singer is torn between loyalty to them both as she wonders “which of them do I betray?

The first of the album’s two covers comes with a bluesy take on Utah Phillips’ ‘Rock Salt And Nails’ featuring West on Dobro, reprising an association with the song from when he toured with the late Kate Wolf in the 80s. The second non-original closes the album, a version of Dougie MacLean’s much covered ‘Caledonia’, Gallup’s delivery evoking a poignancy I thought had long been squeezed out by overfamiliarity.

Between the two are the three remaining self-penned numbers, ‘The Weapon Of Choice’, another family-related song which, accompanied by Witcher’s forlorn fiddle, talks of receiving a telephone call from her mother (about her father’s death, perhaps) that “made a hole in my heart”.

The only vaguely uptempo number here, ‘Unravel’ is a burbling banjo, swamp and Appalachia hybrid blues written in the wake of tending to someone with a serious illness (“it’s only hair, he said, and I said it will grow back”) and how it made her want to cling to every moment, before returning to family once more for ‘Raised By Wolves’, a fiddle scraping, waltzingly playful portrait of what, if are to believe the lyrics (“My mother found fault with my father, my grandparents slept in twin beds… my brother could jimmy the lock…my step sister bullied the cops”), was a seriously dysfunctional, but decidedly interesting family where the narrator “would hide under my quilt with a flashlight, write poetry over their heads”. Regardless of whether it’s Gallup’s family or not, she is, after all, a storyteller, it’s a terrific song on an album that, like its title, offers a haunting listen.

Mike Davies

Please support us and order via our UK or US Storefront 

Click banner above to order featured CD/ Vinyl/ Download/ Book/ DVD
Physical link for the UK Store is:

Click banner above to order featured CD/ Vinyl/ Download/ Book/ DVD
Physical link to the US Store

Buying through Amazon on helps us to recover a small part of our running costs, so please order anything you need as every little purchase helps us. Can’t find what you are looking for? Search Amazon Store below.

Artist’s website:

‘West Memphis Arkansas’ – official video: